Can an HOA restrict what homeowners say or display? In this episode of The Uncommon Area, host Matthew Holbrook sits down with attorney Sarah A. Paas of Tinnelly Law Group to unpack one of the most misunderstood issues in community living: free speech rights inside an HOA.

They explore what the First Amendment actually protects, how California law extends additional rights to residents, and where the line is drawn between commercial and non-commercial speech. From political signs to social media posts, this conversation breaks down what HOAs can and cannot regulate, and how boards can set fair, compliant rules that respect freedom of expression while maintaining community harmony.

If you’re an HOA board member, community manager, or homeowner, this episode will help you navigate speech rights, signage rules, and practical policies that protect both values and voices.

Follow The Uncommon Area for expert-led discussions on HOA law, governance, and property management best practices. Rather watch the episode video? Subscribe to our YouTube Channel!

Have a topic you’d like covered? Email us at marketing@actionlife.com or follow us on Facebook, Instagram or LinkedIn.