In Gabrielle's captivity, Andrew reveals that he knows she put the Vampire Curse on Zachariah Clayton, and tells her hates her.

Mark worries about Andrew, and Alison worries about Mark. But when Mark goes to visit Stanford, he finds Andrew has returned.

Mark and Alison conduct a seance to contact the spirit of Zachariah Clayton, hoping he can help them find Andrew and Gabrielle.

Holly scolds Toby in the hospital, and tries to convince him to accept Andrew fully into the family.

After being called by David Clayton in the middle of the night, Mark searches the First Home for the missing Toby and Andrew.

Andrew and Toby explore the First Home after Toby reveals that Zachariah Clayton lived there many years ago.

Andrew expresses his fears about Gabrielle to Holly, who tries to help him strengthen his resolve to leave the witch for good.

Mark enlists the help of an old flame, Alison Simmons, to help Andrew protect himself from Gabrielle.

Mark tries to reach out in peace to Stanford, but it does not go well. Mark refuses to forgive Andrew. Andrew finally opens up about the witch he is attempting to hide from.

Andrew despairs over Mark's fury, and Holly suggests he call Mark and try to make amends.