Leslie said "Yes" to Matt's proposal of marriage but hasn't committed to a second date. Sure, it was a sham proposal for free stuff from a restaurant but that's sweet too, right?

The woman on the phone says her life was changed forever after meeting a guy at a coffee shop... Which was pretty inspiring... Until we learned the bizarre truth behind it all....

Before we even made today’s Second Date call, our listener was 99.9% sure they knew the reason they were being avoided. Nevertheless, we’re on the case and on the hunt for some love redemption!

One listener reunited with his high school crush and spent HUNDREDS of dollars to make sure he didn't lose her AGAIN... But did his expensive idea backfire?!

One of our listeners took a risk and invited a guy back to her place on their first date. Ever since then, he’s been avoiding her. Did she scare him off or is there another explanation??

The guy on the phone today takes kindness to a whole new level... He even offered to take his date to her EX-husband's wedding. But is it possible to be TOO nice?

One of our listeners crossed the line and breached our trust! We were rooting for him..... Until he BETRAYED us... Even Jeffrey is still disappointed!

Is giving a gift on a first date going too far? What one listener thought was thoughtful and sweet...Might have turned out to be weird and creepy...

Our self-proclaimed BIGGEST FAN is on the phone today! We can't let him down...It's time to bring our A GAME.

There's one word to describe this date...DISASTROUS. Nothing stayed on the right track and now one of our listeners needs help redeeming herself!