When you rent a car in Ireland, one of the first choices you’ll face is manual vs automatic. For North American travelers, it’s a question you might not even think to ask – but the difference in price is bigger than you imagine.

Why Choosing a Transmission Is a Rental Choice in Ireland

In North America it’s nearly impossible to rent a manual transmission car – everything is automatic. In Ireland, it’s the reverse. Manuals are the standard, so when you book your rental you’ll have to decide between the two.

Renting a Car & Driving in Ireland
The One-Stop Resource for EVERYTHING You Need to Know

Why Manuals Are Standard in Ireland

In Ireland, manual transmission cars aren’t the budget option – they’re the default. Manuals are cheaper to buy, easier to maintain, and more fuel efficient, so rental companies fill their fleets with them.

Most Irish drivers also learn on a manual. If you pass your test in a manual, you’re licensed to drive both manual and automatic. But if you test in an automatic, you can only drive automatics. That flexibility keeps manuals in demand.

There’s also a bit of tradition at play: many locals feel manuals handle Ireland’s narrow roads, sharp curves, and hills better.

The Shocking Cost Difference

Here’s where the surprise comes in: automatics can cost two to three times more than manuals.

For example, when I checked rates with my preferred rental company, Irish Car Rentals, a week in a small manual car came in at just $100. The same size car with an automatic transmission? Over $360.

That’s a massive difference – and it’s average. During peak travel season, the gap can be even larger because automatics are in short supply and sell out quickly.

If you know you’ll need an automatic, book as far in advance as possible to secure one and avoid last-minute sticker shock.

Which Should You Choose?

• Choose a manual if:
  You’re already comfortable driving stick and don’t mind shifting with your left hand. It doesn’t take long to adjust, and you’ll save a significant amount of money.
• Choose an automatic if:
  You’d rather keep your focus on driving on the left side of the road and navigating Ireland’s narrow lanes. If a manual makes you nervous, the extra cost of an automatic is absolutely worth it for peace of mind.

Choosing the Car That Fits Your Trip

Manuals are standard in Ireland, while automatics are limited and cost more. The right choice is the one that makes your trip enjoyable and stress-free.