In the latest episode of “The Perceptive Photographer,” I dip my toe back into the pool of critiquing photographs. Critique is more than just forming an opinion; it’s a structured approach to understanding and evaluating photographic work. In this episode, I’ll try to offer up some advice to help you improve your critique skills. We start with a Quick Look at critical Theory and m ethodology

• 
  
• Critical Theory: This refers to the assumptions and ideas we bring to the critique. It has its roots in academic discussions, such as those from Frankfurt University, where it was initially developed to study Marxism and consumerism. In the art world, this concept helps us analyze and interpret various forms of artistic expression.
  
• Methodology: This encompasses the specific processes we use to analyze the work. Different methodologies can lead to varied interpretations of the same photograph, highlighting the subjective nature of art critique.
  
• 
  

As I have discusses many times on the podcast, one my the core principle in the critique process is the importance of suspending judgment. It’s crucial to set aside initial assumptions about a photograph—whether you perceive it as good, bad, or interesting—until you’ve thoroughly examined it. This approach allows for a more objective analysis and helps prevent personal biases from clouding your critique.

Many of us, myself included, often seek to validate our initial beliefs about a photograph rather than objectively assess its merits. This tendency can lead to a skewed critique process, where we force our opinions onto the work instead of allowing the work to inform our understanding. It’s essential to approach critique with an open mind, letting the photograph guide your analysis. When critiquing a photograph, consider the questions you’re asking yourself and the motivations behind your critique. For instance:

• 
  
• What am I trying to understand?
  
• Is it the technique, the concept, or the emotional impact of the work?
  

By clarifying these questions, you can better navigate your critique process and gain deeper insights into the work.Conclusion

Critiquing photographs can be a challenging process. By suspending judgment, asking the right questions, exploring different methodologies, and considering the context, you can approach critique with greater clarity and intention. Engaging in meaningful dialogue and participating in critique workshops can further enhance your skills and appreciation for the art of photography.

I hope episode 516 can help you improve your critique skills a bit. Always remember, the goal is not just to evaluate a photograph but to understand and appreciate the depth and complexity of the work.

Gear used in the podcast

Rode Boom Arm
Rode PSM Shockmount
Rode Podcast Mic
Focusrite Scarlet 2i2
Adobe Audition (part of creative cloud subscription)
Macbook Pro
OWC Thunderbolt 3 dock