Today's episode features special guest co-host, Caleb, from Horror Soup! Paige and Caleb discuss the life and times of the club kids, the death of Angel Melendez, the movie Party Monster, as well as some Nelson Sullivan's home videos that document a...

Sixteen is the number of times Ezra McCandless stabbed Alex Woodworth. Caught in a love triangle with Alex and Jason Mengal, she wanted Alex out of her life. In her mind, Alex was the reason she and Jason were no longer together. This is a story of a...

A few months ago, Eric Landin, of the podcast True Consequences, came on and discussed what happened to his baby brother, Jacob. He has been on a quest for justice for over 30 years. On the podcast, Riddle Me That! True Crime, join host Dr. Jules...

At 16 years old, Rod Ferrell was obsessed with vampires. He believed he was a 500 year old vampire named Vesago. Rod was sired into a vampire cult by drinking the blood of another. He had a friendship with a girl named Heather Wendorf. She said her...

Sandra Bland was a strong, amazing, lively young woman from Naperville, Illinois. Sandra was a civil rights activist who always voiced her opinions about police brutality and various other topics under the hashtag #SandySpeaks on social media. She was...

Part two of our discussion about the tragic death of Rebecca Zahau! Go check out Riddle Me That by Dr. Jules! Sources: Rebecca Zahau: An ID Murder Mystery Death at the Mansion: Rebecca Zahau (Oxygen network)...

In 2011, a 6 year old boy, Max Shacknai, would take a fall from the second floor banister, and this would set off a chain of events. In the wake of the tragedy, not only this young boy, but also the father Jonah's girlfriend of three years, Rebecca...

Tara Lynn was successful at her job and as a mother. Her husband, Stephen, didn’t like the fact that she wasn‘t at home as much as he thought she should be, due to her job involving a good amount of traveling. She was the breadwinner of the family. In...

Elizabeth was 9 years old, making her way to her friend Emma’s house as she normally did. Emma was 6 years old at the time and she had a 15 year old half sister named Alyssa. Alyssa was a troubled teenager with a sad past. She had a lot of pent up...

In 1982, Johnny was a 12 year old paperboy. He was always on time to deliver the Sunday paper. The one time he failed to wake his dad up to tag along with him is the day he would never be seen again. To this day, people still want to know: Where is...