Jewish History Soundbites

Jewish History Soundbites


Zionists, Messianists or Immigrants? The Talmidei Hagra & The Controversy of the Kol Hator

January 14, 2020

In 1947 a book was published in Jerusalem bearing the title "Kol Hator". It ascribed Messianic overtones to the immigration of a group of students of the Vilna Goan nearly two centuries earlier, with the accompanying claim that they were the original Zionists. The book itself was allegedly written by R Hillel Rivlin, one of those talmidim who came during that period. But was it?
Who wrote the book? What motivated the author? Why did the students of the Vilna Goan - and the earlier Chassidic Aliya for that matter - move to the land of Israel at the turn of the Nineteenth Century? Was there immigration a Messianic or Nationalistic endeavor?
And most of all, how is that legacy a relevant story today in the tense polemics of both scholarly as well as public discourse?

Subscribe To Our Podcast on:
Apple: tinyurl.com/yy8gaody
Google Play: tinyurl.com/yxwv8tpc
Spotify: tinyurl.com/y54wemxs
Stitcher: bit.ly/2GxiKTJ

Follow us on Twitter or Instagram at @Jsoundbites

You can email Yehuda at YGebss@Gmail.com