Inside Creative Writing
How to Hook a Reader: The Power of First Impressions in Writing
The Power of First Impressions in Writing
— a podcast episode —
Confirmation bias in writing influences how readers, agents, and publishers perceive a book based on first impressions. Titles, covers, formatting, and opening sentences create an initial bias that shapes how the rest of the work is judged. Writers can use this effect to their advantage by crafting strong, engaging openings that encourage positive reader expectations.
Helping writers craft authentic, immersive stories.
Find out more about us here.
Inside Creative Writing
-
Email this Page
-
Share on Bluesky
-
Share on LinkedIn
-
Share on Pinterest
-
Share on Reddit
-
Share on Threads
-
Share on Facebook
- Understanding Confirmation Bias and Its Power in Writing
- The Power of First Impressions
- Confirmation Bias in Writing and Publishing
- Choosing the Right Author Name
- Your Author Photo: More Important Than You Think
- The Subtle Power of Email and Social Media Handles
- Crafting a Book Title That Stands Out
- Your Book Cover: Your Most Important Marketing Tool
- The First Sentence: How to Hook a Reader
- Wise Words: Jorge Luis Borges on Falling in Love with Writing
- Weekly Challenge: Analyze First Sentences
Every writer wants their story to be unputdownable, but hooking a reader isn’t just about throwing in action or flashy prose. It’s about crafting an opening that instantly builds curiosity, trust, and engagement. In this episode of Inside Creative Writing, we break down the psychology behind first impressions and explore how confirmation bias affects the way readers, agents, and publishers perceive your work.
You’ll discover the hidden power of your book’s title, cover, and first line—and how small, strategic changes can make your manuscript impossible to ignore. Whether you’re struggling to make your opening pages shine or wondering why some books seem to demand attention while others go unnoticed, this episode is packed with actionable insights you can use today.
By the end of this episode, you will…
- Understand why first impressions matter and how they shape a reader’s perception of your work.
- Learn how to craft a compelling opening sentence that pulls readers in.
- Discover how book titles, cover design, and even your author name impact a reader’s willingness to engage.
- Identify small but powerful tweaks that make your writing stand out from the competition.
Listen to the full episode or skim the edited transcript with relevant links below.
At Inside Creative Writing, we believe in practical, hands-on storytelling techniques—not just abstract theory. That’s why this episode gives you real-world examples and exercises to sharpen your openings and instantly make your work more engaging.
Formatted and Edited Transcript Understanding Confirmation Bias and Its Power in WritingConfirmation bias is a psychological principle that influences the way we perceive information, and as writers, we can harness it to shape how readers, agents, and publishers interpret our work. Today, we’re going to explore what confirmation bias is, how it affects first impressions, and how you can use it to your advantage when crafting a novel, screenplay, or any other written work.
The Power of First ImpressionsI had heard the term confirmation bias before, but it wasn’t until I saw a segment on the show Brain Games that I truly understood its significance. In this episode, a group of people was recruited to act as hiring managers. They were given two nearly identical job candidates to interview—twins who looked and acted the same. The only difference? The order in which they described their qualities.
One candidate listed her positive attributes first, saying she was serious, hardworking, and creative, before mentioning that she was also moody, nitpicky, and brutally honest. The other candidate listed the same words but in reverse order—starting with the negatives. Despite being identical in every way except for word order, 80% of the hiring managers chose the first candidate.
What happened? The interviewers formed an initial impression based on the first few words they heard. Once they developed a positive expectation, they subconsciously dismissed the negative traits. This is confirmation bias in action. Once we make up our minds about something—whether it’s a job candidate, a book, or a piece of writing—we naturally seek out information that confirms that belief and ignore or downplay contradictory evidence.
As writers, understanding confirmation bias helps us see why first impressions are crucial. We need to know how to hook a reader from the very first sentence. If we get them on our side early, they’ll overlook minor missteps. But if their initial impression is negative, everything else in our writing will be scrutinized through that lens.
Confirmation Bias in Writing and PublishingThis principle applies everywhere, from politics to academia to publishing. Professors, for example, often form an opinion about a student’s work before even reading it—based on formatting alone. A well-formatted essay creates an expectation of quality, leading professors to be more forgiving of minor errors. On the other hand, if the font size is too big, the margins are stretched, or the format is sloppy, that negative first impression makes every subsequent mistake seem like proof that the student isn’t a strong writer.
Now, think about how this applies to books. Whether it’s a potential reader on Amazon, an agent considering representation, or a publisher deciding whether to invest in your manuscript, first impressions matter. Everything from your name to your book title to the first few lines of your story shapes how people perceive your work. If they start with a positive bias, they’ll be looking for reasons to love your book. If they start with a negative bias, they’ll be searching for flaws.
Choosing the Right Author NameYour name is one of the first things readers and industry professionals see, and it plays a role in shaping their perception of you. Some people are fortunate enough to have names that naturally sound like “writer names.” Others may need to consider whether their given name is memorable, professional, and easy to spell.
Mindy Kaling, for example, was born Vera Mindy Chokalingam. She shortened her last name because she realized that a difficult-to-pronounce name could make it harder for people to remember and recommend her work. This isn’t about abandoning your identity—it’s about branding and accessibility.
In my case, my given name is Brad Thompson. While not a bad name, I decided to write under my middle name, Brad Reed. It’s shorter, easier to remember, and has a subtle connection to literature (as in “read” a book). It also offers a degree of anonymity, which is valuable for a writer who is also a teacher.
Your name is your brand. It’s the first thing people see on your book cover, website, or query letter. If it’s forgettable, hard to spell, or blends in with others, you might want to consider a pen name. It’s not about tricking anyone—it’s about making it easier for your readers to find and remember you.
Your Author Photo: More Important Than You ThinkLike it or not, we judge books by their covers—and we judge authors by their photos. If you’re using an author photo, make sure it represents you and your writing style. A lighthearted, quirky author might get away with a playful image, but if you’re writing literary fiction or serious nonfiction, a professional headshot might be the better choice.
Having a high-quality phone camera doesn’t make someone a professional photographer. Composition, lighting, and subtle details all matter. A poorly taken author photo can create a subconscious impression that the book itself is amateurish. If possible, invest in a professional photographer to capture an image that reinforces the credibility of your work.
The Subtle Power of Email and Social Media HandlesYour email address, website, and social media handles also shape first impressions. If you’re still using an old “@yahoo.com” address or an email leftover from middle school, consider switching to something more professional. Ideally, your email address should be linked to your own domain (e.g., yourname@yourwebsite.com). This small change signals to agents, publishers, and readers that you take your writing career seriously.
The same goes for social media handles. Whenever possible, your Twitter, Instagram, and other profiles should match your author brand. If someone is searching for you, they should easily be able to find you across different platforms.
Crafting a Book Title That Stands OutOne of the biggest mistakes new writers make is choosing a generic book title. Titles like Before We Met, When You Were Here, or Until We Meet Again blend into a sea of similar books. Instead, you need a title that is unique, memorable, and specific to your story.
Consider bestsellers like Girl, Wash Your Face; Crazy Rich Asian; or The President Is Missing. Each of these titles immediately creates an image or a sense of curiosity. When you choose your title, Google it to see if similar titles exist. If there are already multiple books with the same name, it might be worth reconsidering.
Your Book Cover: Your Most Important Marketing ToolA poorly designed book cover screams “self-published” in the worst way. It’s one of the biggest reasons potential readers hesitate to buy indie books. Even if your story is incredible, an unprofessional cover can ruin your chances of hooking a reader. Invest in a professional designer who understands market trends and genre expectations.
The First Sentence: How to Hook a ReaderAll of these factors—the name, the title, the cover—determine whether a potential reader even opens your book. But once they do, everything hinges on the first sentence. That opening line sets the stage for everything that follows. If it’s weak, readers will assume the rest of the book is weak. If it’s compelling, it primes them to look for more things to love.
A great first sentence introduces intrigue, character, or setting in a way that immediately pulls the reader in. It doesn’t have to be action-packed, but it must create curiosity. It must create a little mystery that makes the reader eager to turn the page.
Wise Words: Jorge Luis Borges on Falling in Love with WritingThis week’s wise words come from Argentine writer Jorge Luis Borges:
“One falls in love with a line, then with a page, then with an author. Well, why not? It is a beautiful process.”
This perfectly encapsulates how to hook a reader. When readers love the first line, they trust the writer and eagerly read on. But if that first line falls flat, they may never give the rest of the book a chance.
Weekly Challenge: Analyze First SentencesThis week, surround yourself with books you love. Read the first sentence of each and analyze what makes them work. Then, look at your own first sentence. Does it stand up? Does it create a compelling reason for the reader to turn the page?
By mastering how to hook a reader, you ensure that their confirmation bias works in your favor—so they’re not looking for reasons to put your book down, but for reasons to keep reading.
Want to take your storytelling to the next level?Your opening pages set the tone for everything that follows. If you want to make a lasting impact, start by mastering the fundamentals of storytelling. Explore our How to Write a Novel guide for more in-depth strategies on crafting a compelling narrative from page one.
Talk to Us!We’d love to hear from you! If you have a question, a comment, a suggestion, or just want to tell us about your work-in-progress, give us a shout!
info@insidecreativewriting.com
Visit Podcast Website
RSS Podcast Feed
Subscribe
Share
Add to MyCast
