AOD – IC之音竹科廣播 FM97.5

AOD – IC之音竹科廣播 FM97.5


希望與失望工程評選,河溪網為台灣河川找「溪」望

April 02, 2025

河川三面光、河床挖深、植被剷除……當一條河流被「整治」之後,它的生態還能恢復嗎?

為了檢視台灣河川治理的成效,台灣河溪網自2019年起舉辦「金蘋果/爛蘋果獎」,邀請專家學者及公民評審團針對前瞻基礎建設全國水環境改善計畫,評選出優良及不當工程,以達到鼓勵及政策監督效果。 ​

隨著全國水環境改善計畫的結束,這項活動轉型為「台灣河川希望工程獎」與「失望工程評選」,河溪網與荒野保護協會攜手,持續透過公民參與,評選出生態友善的整治案例,鼓勵投入河川復育的公私部門,同時指出對生態造成嚴重衝擊的不當治理課題,並促進制度研議改進,避免類似案例再度發生。

本屆得獎作品令人驚嘆!「竹溪水岸改善及環境營造工程」成功克服土地違規占用及垃圾清理等長年棘手問題,為台南市民提供了一個舒適的親水公園;「景美溪及指南溪匯流口護岸再造工程」拆除計畫範圍指南溪左岸護岸、移除河床封底的混凝土,改善河川的橫向與垂直連結;「秀巒降壩首部曲」拆除秀巒壩部分結構,恢復部分土砂運移功能,改善白石溪的縱向連結。

值得一提的是,「種瓜坑野溪復育工程」拆除南投種瓜坑溪高聳的護岸,並進行小型洪泛平原復育,是全國首例由私人地主主動發起的河川復育案例;「田寮洋一二三圳取水設施更新改善工程」大規模拆除遠望坑溪3道抬水堰及11座固床工,改良取水方式並改善長達此溪段的生態環境,成為台灣首次完全實踐「近自然工法」精神的河川工程。

評審團隊也選出了本屆的台灣河川失望工程──烏溪雙冬堤防工程於河川的辮狀流上大量填土、宜蘭五十溪野溪復建工程將野溪水泥化。從這些負面案例中分析得知,傳統的工程思維慣性、環評的制度缺失、生態檢核的定位、民眾的認知差距,與用地限制,都可能是導致河川工程無法兼顧生態的原因。

真正友善的河川治理,應該回應生態需求,同時考量地方發展與民眾參與。今天的《島嶼共聲.傾聽台灣》,就來看這些希望/失望工程,給我們的啟示。

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