In this episode of the Fully-Booked Podcast, hosts Meaghan and Arthur continue their discussion of villains in literature, focusing on cases where a villain in an adaptation surpasses their literary counterpart. Building on last week's episode about what makes a great villain, they explore how actors, screenwriting, direction, and visual design can elevate a character beyond what was on the page.

The hosts identify several key factors that contribute to a villain’s success in an adaptation;

• Actor Performance: A compelling performance can make a villain more memorable than they were in the book.
• Screenwriting: A well-adapted screenplay that preserves or enhances a character’s depth is crucial.
• Visual Design: How a character is brought to life visually, from makeup to CGI, can shape their impact.
• Direction and Editing: Filmmaking choices, including deleted scenes or script changes, can significantly affect how a villain is perceived.
• Memorable Dialogue and Physicality: An actor’s unique take, such as mannerisms or improvisation, can elevate a character’s presence.

Not all villains in adaptations are created equal - some fade into the background, while others become legendary. What sets them apart? The hosts break down the crucial elements that can elevate a villain beyond their literary origins, making them unforgettable on screen.

The hosts identify several key factors and villains that were unforgettable in an adaptation:

Ralph Fiennes' portrayal of Voldemort remains iconic due to the combination of chilling voice work, visual effects (snake-like face), and the character’s presence as a terrifying antagonist.

Anthony Perkins’ performance in Psycho made Norman Bates a defining horror villain. The psychological depth and iconic scenes enhanced the character far beyond his literary origin.

Despite only having around thirteen minutes of screen time, Anthony Hopkins' portrayal of Hannibal Lecter overshadowed the novel’s version of the character, making him one of the most recognized villains in film history.

Clay’s Bang’s version of Dracula is praised for its mixture of menace and charm. The performance, alongside strong visual and narrative choices, made this adaptation particularly memorable.

Kathy Bates' portrayal of Annie Wilkes was so intense that it arguably surpassed Stephen King’s original character. Her performance added layers of disturbing realism to the obsessive fan.

Christian Bale’s chilling yet darkly comedic take on Bateman turned the character into a pop culture phenomenon. The film’s direction also enhanced the unreliable narrator aspect, making it a standout adaptation.

While Tim Curry’s Pennywise from the 1990 miniseries was iconic, Bill Skarsgård’s portrayal in the IT films added a new level of horror. The updated effects, performance, and physicality made this version far scarier.

David Tennant’s chilling performance as Kilgrave, a mind-controlling villain, made him one of the most disturbing Marvel villains on screen, standing out in a sea of forgettable antagonists.

Vincent D’Onofrio’s Kingpin provided a level of complexity rarely seen in Marvel adaptations. His nuanced performance gave depth to a character that could have been a one-dimensional crime boss.

Margaret Hamilton’s portrayal in the 1939 film defined the modern image of a wicked witch. Her green skin, cackling voice, and menacing presence became the gold standard for villainous witches in media.

While some villains thrive in adaptations, others fall flat due to poor writing, miscasting, or studio interference. The hosts highlight how deleted scenes, studio-mandated changes, and rushed scripts can negatively impact a villain’s effectiveness on screen.

Certain villains become scarier or more impactful when visualized on screen. Pennywise is a perfect example - while terrifying in the book, the added horror of seeing him on screen, paired with Bill Skarsgård’s unsettling performance, made the character even more chilling.

The hosts speculate on book villains they’d love to see brought to life in adaptations. One example is the mental parasite antagonist from the Red Space series, which could be a fascinating challenge for filmmakers. Another is the vampire from The Southern Book Club’s Guide to Slaying Vampires, which is set to be adapted by HBO.

Villains can make or break a story, and some adaptations enhance or even redefine them for new audiences. Whether through compelling performances, strong writing, or striking visuals, these villains have cemented themselves as unforgettable figures in pop culture.

Next week, Meaghan and Arthur will discuss the distinction between villains, anti-heroes, and morally gray characters.