Last week, in Batgirl #49 - a comic with an apparent target demographic of Millennials - writer Cameron Stewart and artist Babs Tarr told a story that could be seen as retconning the events of Alan Moore's and Brian Bolland's 1988 one-shot, Batman: The Killing Joke.In the wake of that story, Stewart argued that his story could be seen as a retconning of The Killing Joke, or not, depending on how you interpret the story... as if the plot of a story that is intertwined in almost 30 years of DC history and countless dozens of titles and stories could be considered subjective to "your own personal truth."

During that same week, another comics podcast - one hosted by Millennials - that we greatly respect did an episode calling The Killing Joke problematic due to its treatment of Barbara Gordon, and arguably overrated and unnecessary.

These attitudes toward The Killing Joke are somewhat understandable, given the concept of "women in refrigerators" that arose in comics fandom in 1999, and the fact that Moore chose to have Joker sexually assault Barbara Gordon in the story. Because of these elements, it's easy to dismiss the story as dated and problematic... especially if you weren't alive and actively reading comics in 1988.

Which we were. Which means that we remember that Barbara Gordon wasn't Batgirl at the time of The Killing Joke. And that The Joker wasn't really defined as a character at all after Crisis On Infinite Earths until The Killing Joke. And that comics fandom was, at the time, strongly against even Robin, let alone any character from the 1966 Batman television show.

So we decided to, at least up to a point, defend The Killing Joke. Not just from a historical standpoint, but from one of story, questioning whether Barbara was, in fact, fridged in the classic sense... while still agreeing that the sexual assault aspect of the story is completely unnecessary, and asking once question we've never seen asked: why didn't Moore just have Joker kill Barbara?

We also discuss Escape From New York #15, written by Christopher Sebela with art by Maxim Simic, and Doctor Strange #6, written by Jason Aaron with art by Chris Bachalo!