Consider This! | Conservative political commentary in 10 minutes or less

Consider This! | Conservative political commentary in 10 minutes or less


Episode 103: The State of Journalism, and What RFRA Doesn’t Protect

April 27, 2015

Another media reporter, Lisa Meyers, has spoken out on the problem she sees in her former profession; journalism. While she may not have al the same issues as Sharyl Attkisson had, her concern is very similar. The media are taking sides.

Some might consider that Fox News is the major culprit, but Sharyl was from CBS and Lisa is from NBC, and both speak primarily to what they experienced themselves. And if you're peeved at how Fox does news, there's a way to fix that, which involves building a better "fox-trap".

I discussed the Indiana Religious Freedom Restoration Act last time, but this time I have a great example of what RFRA is not going to protect. Actual discrimination against people is not covered. Refusal to participate in an event might still be. Two very different things.

Mentioned links:

Lisa Myers: TV journalism deteriorating (http://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/life/2015/03/10/lisa-myers-tv-journalism-deteriorating/24745029/)

Fox News is the most trusted national news channel. And it’s not that close. (http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-fix/wp/2015/03/09/fox-news-is-the-most-trusted-national-news-channel-and-its-not-that-close/)

Michigan Auto Shop Owner Faces Backlash After Declaring He Won’t Serve Gays (http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2015/04/16/michigan-auto-shop-owner-faces-backlash-after-declaring-he-wont-serve-gays/)

Show transcript

On this podcast, I’ve highlighted the case of Sharyl Attkisson, who left CBS because her investigative reporting on the Obama administration kept getting cut and shelved by the network. She went out and wrote a book about it, called “Stonewalled”. Lisa Meyers was a reporter for NBC, and left that network about a year ago. While it appears she left after decades just because she was ready to move on, some answers to interview questions recently caught my attention. While she might not make common cause with Attkisson completely, she did have something to say about the state of journalism today.

When asked, “What is the state of TV journalism today?”, she answered:
I am going to talk about the deterioration in the quality of journalism you see on TV. I think the primary mission of journalism is to hold the powerful accountable, be they in government or corporate America. There is less and less interest in network television today holding the White House or any other part of government accountable. I fear there is a calculation that the audiences they are trying to reach don't care that much about the serious news. I think most of the political coverage these days has all the depth of Twitter.

I also worry that journalists today appear to have chosen sides when it comes to political coverage. I think you see that in the sagging approval numbers of TV news over the last few years. We've seen trust in the media hit its lowest level ever in 2013 or 2014 surveys and I think the lack of depth and the feeling that too many journalists have chosen sides has caused viewers to question whether we are giving it to them straight and whether we are making a politically balanced presentation.

My observation would be that networks are holding the powerful accountable less and less during a Democratic administration. It seems to be dipping these days just because Obama is in the Oval Office. Put a Republican in there, and I’ll bet the “primary mission” will become primary again. But with her leaving at this point, I can see how she might consider this a trend. Certainly, it is happening.
Additionally, her worry that journalists have chosen sides is telling. She’s coming from NBC, and Attkisson came from CBS, and both have similar concerns. Some might charge that Meyers is probably talking about Fox News, but then she talks about the sagging approval numbers of TV news. That’s not happening at Fox; that’s an issue with the broadcast networks, and MSNBC. Fox is currently the most trusted news network, so considering that,