We're talking about Minutes 61-62 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which Long John finishes singing and the bad guys capture the Hispaniola. With special guest Julia Gaskill!PLUS: Other pirate media! Who is the rightful owner of the treasure? A Troll i

We're talking about Minutes 59-60 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which Long John Silver continues singing "Professional Pirate," his ONLY number. With special guest Louie Pearlman!PLUS: Why do the Spanish despise Sir Francis Drake? Why IS e

We're talking about Minutes 57-58 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which the Electric Mayhem jams and Tim Curry sings "Professional Pirate." With special guest Richard Michael Gomez!PLUS: Water-skiing rats! Floyd and Zoot speak! Appreciating

We're talking about Minutes 55-56 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which Kermit has a cunning plan to get rid of the pirates, but it's not gonna work. With special guest Will Carroll!PLUS: Everyone repeats everything! Spoilers for Gilmore Girls sea

We're talking about Minutes 53-54 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which Jim and the boys overhear an evil plan and the crew spots the island. With special guest Katilyn Miller! PLUS: The famous apple barrel scene! The barrel is bigger on the inside! H

We're talking about Minutes 51-52 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which Mr. Arrow takes a boat trip and everyone is sad about it. With special guest Katilyn Miller!PLUS: Bald eagles can't swim! Another delightful Tim Curry moment! Does Long John r

We're talking about Minutes 49-50 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which Jim says too much and Sam tests a lifeboat. With special guest Grant Harding!PLUS: Jim is an idiot! What is Long John thinking? A brief history of foghorns! Whose nickname is &quo

We're talking about Minutes 47-48 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which the crew gets over their "Cabin Fever" and Long John feels guilty. With special guest Erik Adams of IGN! PLUS: What's a wienerschnitzel? Spooky organ music! What exa

We're talking about Minutes 45-46 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which the crew of the Hispaniola gets "Cabin Fever." With special guest Matthew Soberman!PLUS: Is this the silliest Muppet movie song? Movie magic with a garbage barge! Are th

We're talking about Minutes 43-44 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which Gonzo's arms are restored to their normal length and Jim gives up the map. With special guest Benjamin Strand!PLUS: What's in a "black rat" cocktail? Gonzo's